Second Judge Indefinitely Blocks Trump’s 250-Foot Memorial Arch

A Virginia federal judge issued a preliminary injunction with no specified end date, finding defects in the administration’s review and saying Trump’s proposed memorial arch lacks congressional approval.
A second federal judge has blocked President Donald Trump’s administration from starting construction on his proposed 250-foot memorial arch near Arlington National Cemetery, replacing a short-term pause in a separate case with an injunction that has no specified expiration date.
U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema announced the preliminary injunction from the bench in Alexandria, Virginia, on Friday, November 20. The Associated Press reported that the order came in a lawsuit filed by the Arlington County Board. Reuters separately reported Brinkema’s findings that the project’s legal and administrative foundation was deficient.
Judge points to missing analysis and congressional approval
Brinkema said federal officials had not adequately analyzed the project’s economic and environmental effects. She singled out the government’s treatment of the proposed structure’s effect on nearby Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport, calling the planning process a “rushed job,” according to Reuters.
The judge also rejected the administration’s reliance on a 1925 law that authorized a pair of columns at the site but was never carried out. She told government lawyers that the argument weakened their credibility and said the arch project lacked congressional approval. That finding addresses one of the central legal disputes surrounding the plan: whether century-old authorization for a different memorial can support construction of a 250-foot arch today.
Arlington County argues that construction at Memorial Circle would worsen traffic and threaten public safety across the Potomac River from Washington. After the hearing, a lawyer for the challengers said the order recognized the risk of irreparable harm while the court considers the case. The White House and Federal Aviation Administration had not immediately commented when Reuters published its report.
A separate order now provides longer protection
The ruling is a material development from the first court-ordered pause, which TrumpInsight covered on November 6. U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington initially barred work for 14 days after the National Capital Planning Commission approved the project. On Wednesday, November 18, she extended that temporary restraint through December 3.
Brinkema’s order comes from a different lawsuit and is broader in duration. The Associated Press reported that it contains no stated end date, unlike Chutkan’s temporary order. A preliminary injunction generally remains in force while litigation proceeds unless it is modified, dissolved or overturned on appeal.
The new order does not amount to a final judgment canceling the arch. It prevents construction while the Virginia case moves forward, and the administration may contest Brinkema’s conclusions or seek appellate review. The underlying questions about congressional authority, environmental review and local effects therefore remain subject to further litigation.
What the project would change
Trump has promoted the arch as a monumental gateway marking the United States’ 250th anniversary. The proposed site is Memorial Circle, between Arlington Memorial Bridge and Arlington National Cemetery. At 250 feet, the structure would be about twice the height of the Lincoln Memorial, according to the Associated Press.
Veterans, architectural preservation advocates, Arlington County and members of the Kennedy family have pursued legal challenges over the project’s scale, location and approval process. The administration has argued that existing authority permits the work, while opponents say a project of this size at a nationally significant site requires new congressional authorization and more complete review.
For now, two federal courts are preventing the administration from breaking ground. Chutkan’s order supplies a date-specific pause through December 3; Brinkema’s preliminary injunction supplies a separate and potentially longer barrier while Arlington County’s claims are heard.
Sources and image credit
- Associated Press via The Morning Sun — second judge blocks construction of Trump’s memorial arch
- Reuters via HuffPost — judge calls the arch a rushed project lacking a legal basis
- The Guardian — construction blocked over review and congressional-approval concerns
- Image source — Historic American Engineering Record view via Wikimedia Commons
- Original image record — Library of Congress